Should I Get Higher Auto Liability or Umbrella Insurance?

Deciding between higher auto liability coverage and an umbrella insurance policy depends on your specific needs and financial situation. Here’s a breakdown to help you make an informed choice:

1. Understanding Both Options

Higher Auto Liability Coverage:

  • What It Covers: Increases the coverage limits of your auto insurance for bodily injury and property damage.
  • Pros: Provides greater protection in the event of an accident where you’re found liable, covering the costs up to the higher limit.
  • Cons: Only applies to incidents involving your car and is limited to the terms of the auto insurance policy.

Umbrella Insurance:

  • What It Covers: Provides extra liability coverage that extends beyond the limits of your auto, home, and other primary insurance policies. It also covers incidents not included in your basic policies, such as libel and slander.
  • Pros: Broader coverage across multiple policies and protection against significant liability claims. It kicks in after the limits of your auto and home insurance are reached.
  • Cons: Typically requires you to have a certain level of liability coverage on your auto policy before you can purchase umbrella insurance.

2. When to Consider Higher Auto Liability Coverage

  • Primary Use for Driving: If most of your risk is tied to driving and you don’t have significant assets, boosting your auto liability limits may be a practical move.
  • Affordability: Sometimes, increasing your auto policy limits can be more affordable in the short term than purchasing a separate umbrella policy.

3. When to Opt for Umbrella Insurance

  • High Net Worth: If you have considerable assets, an umbrella policy offers broader protection, ensuring that you don’t lose those assets if faced with a lawsuit that exceeds your auto insurance limits.
  • Multiple Risks: If you want coverage for various liability risks (e.g., accidents involving your home, vacation property, or other personal situations), an umbrella policy is more comprehensive.
  • Affordability per Dollar of Coverage: Umbrella insurance can be cost-effective because it provides millions in coverage for a relatively low annual premium, usually starting around $150-$300 per year for $1 million in coverage.

4. Cost Comparison

  • Higher Auto Liability: May increase your premiums proportionally to the coverage amount.
  • Umbrella Insurance: Offers more extensive coverage and often provides $1 million+ limits at a modest increase to your overall insurance costs.

5. Examples for Context

  • Higher Auto Liability: If you have a $250,000/$500,000 auto liability limit and you cause an accident that results in $600,000 in medical bills, you’d be responsible for the remaining $100,000+ without higher coverage.
  • Umbrella Insurance: In the same scenario, if your primary auto policy covers up to $500,000, an umbrella policy would kick in and cover the remaining $100,000, plus any additional claims beyond that amount (up to the umbrella’s limit).

Final Thoughts

  • For Limited Risks: Increase your auto liability coverage if you only need protection for driving-related incidents.
  • For Comprehensive Protection: Choose an umbrella policy if you want broader coverage and protection for significant assets or potential large claims.

Best Approach: Many people opt for a combination—having robust auto liability coverage as a base and supplementing it with an umbrella policy for enhanced protection. This offers peace of mind knowing you have an extra layer of safety in case of major incidents.

Leave a Comment